Islamic Calligraphy

Most of these introductory articles are exracted from Volume I of the Single Monad Model of the Cosmos: Ibn al-Arabi's View of Time and Creation... more on this can be found here.

Discreteness and Continuousness

Discreteness and Continuousness:

There is no doubt that Zeno has presented a deep problem which, despite centuries of efforts to resolve it, still seems to lack a truly satisfactory solution. As Frankel wrote:

The human mind, when trying to give itself an accurate account of motion, finds itself confronted with two aspects of the phenomenon. Both are inevitable but at the same time they are mutually exclusive. Either we look at the continuous flow of motion; then it will be impossible for us to think of the object in any particular position. Or we think of the object as occupying any of the positions through which its course is leading it; and while fixing our thought on that particular position we can not help fixing the object itself and putting it at rest for one short instant.

(Frankel 1942: 1-25, 193-206)

This basic dilemma of discreteness and continuousness has kept coming up in various guises, but most clearly in the long historical debate on the nature of light; whether it is particles or waves. With the success of the wave theory in the nineteenth century, the continuum seemed to have won. But in 1899, when Max Planck solved the 'black body problem'[1] by postulating that atoms could absorb or emit energy only in discrete amounts, the age of quantum theory began. Soon after that, Bohr used the concept of quantisation to construct the first successful atomic model, and Einstein was able to analyse the photoelectric effect only by adopting the quantum nature of light. However, the quantum theory was not able to solve the question of motion and change, where the continuous theory of relativity was more successful.

So the human mind is accustomed to classifying quantities as either countable or uncountable, or either discrete or continuous; there is no other way. This is inevitable on the level of multiplicity. But on the level of oneness (i.e., of all-inclusive ahadiyya or 'unicity') there would be no meaning for such terms. A first look at Ibn al-Arabi's model could conclude that, on the level of multiplicity, the world should be certainly discrete, and therefore that Ibn al-Arabi might easily adopt the atomist view. But the issue this raises is quite similar to what we have discussed earlier in Chapter II about the length of the moment and whether it is composed of discrete sub-moments, or whether it has a length at all. We have seen that it is not easy to decide for either case. Similarly, it is not easy to judge - even on the multiplicity level - whether the world is ultimately continuous or discrete. Although there are discrete events happening in discrete times, still the change from one event to another looks continuous, just like the flow of normal days; there is no abrupt change. Although we can easily divide events over days and classify them according to the date, actually the relation between any two consecutive events that happened during the day is not different from those which happened also consecutively but on different days - for example, right before and after morning or evening. In other words, the motion of the earth around its axis, though generating the appearance of different distinct days, it is itself a continuous process. Likewise, the all-creative 'motion' of the Single Monad is also a continuous process in everlasting alteration between 'daytimes' and 'night-times', manifestation and being hidden, material and spiritual - yet there is no point of separation or abrupt transformation between any two periods or states. That is why Ibn al-Arabi calls the terms of discreteness and continuousness 'disconnected' (munfasil) and 'connected' (muttasil), because for him the actual process of change (re-creation) it is like a one-dimensional flow of divine manifestation. So if there is an apparent continuity or discontinuity that would only be in our imagination or abstract consideration, but not in reality [III.324.35-325.18].

========

[1] The black body problem was raised by the observation that certain materials (especially black bodies) can absorb all frequencies or wavelengths of light. So when heated it should then radiate all frequencies of light equally - at least theoretically. But the distribution of energy radiated in real life experiments never matched up with the predictions of classical physics.

Read Other Books:

Single Monad Model of the Cosmos
The Single Monad Model of the Cosmos: Ibn Arabi's View of Time and Creation
The Duality of Time Theory
The Duality of Time Theory: Complex-Time Geometry and Perpertual Creation of Space
The Duality of Time Theory
The Ultimate Symmetry: Fractal Complex-Time and Quantum Gravity
The Chest of Time
The Chest of Time: Particle-Wave Duality: from Time Confinement to Space Transcendence

Read this short concise exploration of the Duality of Time Postulate:

he Duality of Time Postulate
DoT: The Duality of Time Postulate and Its Consequences on General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics

Other Pages Related to Search Keywords:

  • ... Monadology =>:

  • ... Space Transcendence Read this short concise exploration of the Duality of Time Postulate: DoT: The Duality of Time Postulate and Its Consequences on General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics ...


  • ... Discussed Earlier =>:

  • ... evel of multiplicity, the world should be certainly discrete, and therefore that Ibn al-Arabi might easily adopt the atomist view. But the issue this raises is quite similar to what we have DISCUSSED EARLIER in Chapter II about the length of the moment and whether it is composed of discret ...


  • ... Classical Physics =>:

  • ... d it should then radiate all frequencies of light equally - at least theoretically. But the distribution of energy radiated in real life experiments never matched up with the predictions of CLASSICAL PHYSICS . Read Other Books: The Single Monad Model of the Cosmos: Ibn Arabi's View of Time ...


  • ... Wave Theory =>:

  • ... ess and continuousness has kept coming up in various guises, but most clearly in the long historical debate on the nature of light; whether it is particles or waves. With the success of the WAVE THEORY in the nineteenth century, the continuum seemed to have won. But in 1899, when Max Planc ...


  • ... Mutually Exclusive =>:

  • ... rote: The human mind, when trying to give itself an accurate account of motion, finds itself confronted with two aspects of the phenomenon. Both are inevitable but at the same time they are MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE . Either we look at the continuous flow of motion; then it will be impossible for ...


  • ... Quantum Nature =>:

  • ... began. Soon after that, Bohr used the concept of quantisation to construct the first successful atomic model, and Einstein was able to analyse the photoelectric effect only by adopting the QUANTUM NATURE of light. However, the quantum theory was not able to solve the question of motion an ...


  • ... Real Life =>:

  • ... n absorb all frequencies or wavelengths of light. So when heated it should then radiate all frequencies of light equally - at least theoretically. But the distribution of energy radiated in REAL LIFE experiments never matched up with the predictions of classical physics. Read Other Books: ...


  • ... Actual Process =>:

  • ... tion between any two periods or states. That is why Ibn al-Arabi calls the terms of discreteness and continuousness 'disconnected' (munfasil) and 'connected' (muttasil), because for him the ACTUAL PROCESS of change (re-creation) it is like a one-dimensional flow of divine manifestation. So ...


  • ... Events Happening =>:

  • ... not easy to decide for either case. Similarly, it is not easy to judge - even on the multiplicity level - whether the world is ultimately continuous or discrete. Although there are discrete EVENTS HAPPENING in discrete times, still the change from one event to another looks continuous, jus ...


  • ... Photoelectric Effect =>:

  • ... iscrete amounts, the age of quantum theory began. Soon after that, Bohr used the concept of quantisation to construct the first successful atomic model, and Einstein was able to analyse the PHOTOELECTRIC EFFECT only by adopting the quantum nature of light. However, the quantum theory was n ...


  • ... Events Happen =>:

  • ... not easy to decide for either case. Similarly, it is not easy to judge - even on the multiplicity level - whether the world is ultimately continuous or discrete. Although there are discrete EVENTS HAPPEN ing in discrete times, still the change from one event to another looks continuous, jus ...


  • ... Continuous Flow =>:

  • ... itself an accurate account of motion, finds itself confronted with two aspects of the phenomenon. Both are inevitable but at the same time they are mutually exclusive. Either we look at the CONTINUOUS FLOW of motion; then it will be impossible for us to think of the object in any particula ...


Welcome to the Single Monad Model of the Cosmos and Duality of Time Theory
Forgot Password? - [Register]

Message from the Author:

I have no doubt that this is the most significant discovery in the history of mathematics, physics and philosophy, ever!

By revealing the mystery of the connection between discreteness and contintuity, this novel understanding of the complex (time-time) geometry, will cause a paradigm shift in our knowledge of the fundamental nature of the cosmos and its corporeal and incorporeal structures.

Enjoy reading...

Mohamed Haj Yousef


Check this detailed video presentation on "Deriving the Principles of Special, General and Quantum Relativity Based on the Single Monad Model Cosmos and Duality of Time Theory".

Download the Book "DOT: The Duality of Time Postulate and Its Consequences on General Relativity and Quantum Mechanics" or: READ ONLINE .....>>>>



Subsribe to Newsletter:


Because He loves beauty, Allah invented the World with ultimate perfection, and since He is the All-Beautiful, He loved none but His own Essence. But He also liked to see Himself reflected outwardly, so He created (the entities of) the World according to the form of His own Beauty, and He looked at them, and He loved these confined forms. Hence, the Magnificent made the absolute beauty --routing in the whole World-- projected into confined beautiful patterns that may diverge in their relative degrees of brilliance and grace.
paraphrased from: Ibn al-Arabi [The Meccan Revelations: IV.269.18 - trans. Mohamed Haj Yousef]
quote