Skip to content

Cosmology · 05 / Illustrated journey

Do two useful time coordinates represent two physical clocks?

Integrate proper and conformal duration along the same power-law history, using a fixed starting event and one stated normalization.

Proper duration and conformal duration accumulate at different rates along one expanding geometry. Both begin at the same finite event, and a comoving ideal clock measures the proper duration.
Proper duration and conformal duration accumulate at different rates along one expanding geometry. Both begin at the same finite event, and a comoving ideal clock measures the proper duration. Download SVG
01

A coordinate can simplify a calculation without adding a clock

Cosmic proper time is the reading assigned to ideal comoving clocks in the FLRW model. Conformal time is a coordinate chosen to make the radial light-cone equation simple. They describe the same geometry in different variables; their different numerical values do not establish two independently measured temporal dimensions.

This distinction is especially important on a website about dual temporal roles. Inner generation and outer completion are a proposed organization of the source process. They should not be identified automatically with cosmic time and conformal time merely because both pairs contain two temporal expressions. A physical correspondence would require an explicit construction. [C01] [B02]

The laboratory supplies a dimensionless power-law history a(u)=up, where u=t/t₀ and a(1)=1. The starting event is ui=0.1, safely away from the ideal singular limit. The end-time slider selects a later event on that same history.

02

Accumulate both intervals from the same start

Change the exponent and end time. The proper interval grows linearly with u because the observer is comoving. The conformal interval weights each increment by 1/a, so early increments contribute more when the scale factor is small.

Interactive calculation

Play scans End time t/t₀. Step advances it. No animation starts automatically.

Enable JavaScript for adjustable values. The static figure and worked calculation remain available.

At p=1 and u=1, the proper elapsed duration is 0.9 in units of t₀. The conformal interval is ln10≈2.3026 in the chosen normalization. At p=2 with the same endpoints it is nine, while proper duration remains 0.9. Nothing requires those coordinate intervals to have the same numerical value.

At u=1 the instantaneous scale factor is one for every p, so dη/du=1 there. Yet the accumulated conformal intervals differ because their earlier histories differ. A shared rate at one endpoint therefore does not imply a shared elapsed coordinate interval.

03

Treat the logarithmic case explicitly

dη=du/a(u)=u−pdu,   Δτ/t₀=u−ui
Δη=[u1−p−ui1−p]/(1−p),   p≠1
Δη=ln(u/ui),   p=1,   ui=0.1

The logarithm follows by integrating 1/u. It is also the continuous limit of the first expression as p approaches one. A numerical implementation should use the logarithmic branch at p=1 and a stable nearby evaluation, rather than evaluating an indeterminate zero divided by zero.

Writing the radial metric in normalized units gives ds²/(ct₀)²=a²(−dη²+dχ²) when χ is measured in the corresponding comoving length unit. Radial null rays obey dχ=±dη. Their straight coordinate lines simplify causal comparisons, while a material clock still accumulates the metric's proper duration.

Both intervals vanish at the common starting event and increase monotonically for positive u. Their derivatives are respectively one and u−p. For u<1 the conformal rate exceeds one; for u>1 it is less than one. These derivative checks help distinguish an integration error from an unfamiliar coordinate scale.

Changing the conventional normalization of a rescales conformal coordinates together with comoving distances. It does not change the proper duration between fixed physical events. Observable conclusions must therefore be expressed in coordinate-independent comparisons or in fully specified conventions.

For a short interval near u=1, Δη and Δτ/t₀ agree to first order because a=1 there. Over an extended interval the changing scale factor prevents that local approximation from being exact. This gives a simple consistency check connecting the coordinate transformation with its integrated values.

04

Calibrate source order before identifying cosmic duration

An inner update counter can order events without measuring seconds. A model needs a reproducible physical process and a map from its records to duration. If different material clocks respond differently to the same inner operations, a single parameter label cannot by itself establish universal cosmic time. [C01]

The published temporal-asymmetry work concerns reduced dynamics, hidden variables, and memory under stated assumptions. It gives reasons to examine how a record's future depends on retained structure. It does not identify conformal time as a second experimentally observed clock. [P04] [A04]

The finite start used here deliberately avoids making a claim about the entire past. Extending the power law toward u=0 changes whether its conformal integral converges. That mathematical convergence, rather than a comparison of coordinate names, determines the particle-horizon result in the next laboratory.

Read the original cosmological-clocks guide, then continue to horizons. The Relativity sequence explains proper time along noncomoving histories, while Experiments develops the idea of comparing independently calibrated clock responses.

SMONAD

Share and cite

Share this page, or keep a clear reference to the work you are reading.

More platforms
Cite this page

Cite the website explanation

Use this reference for the explanation on this page. “n.d.” means its first publication date is not specified; the update date is recorded separately.